A critique of the chapter 3, “Some Inland Enclaves” of “Canadian English” Akinori
The author, J.K.Chambers mentioned the importance of three inland dialects, such as Montreal, Ottawa and the Red River in “the indications are that a linguistic atlas of Canada would be a worthwhile and almost necessary complement to a dictionary of Canadian English.”
Hence, regarding what I have read in this chapter, one thing I can say is that Americanism has greatly influenced these dialects, forming their variety. Additionally, needless to say, other aspects, such as French and native languages also played roles to some extent; however, the influence of American English was so great that its impact cannot be too emphasized. Moreover, on pronunciation, their distinctiveness appeared more clearly. People using these dialects prefer to use American ways and sometimes British ways, so their inclination of pronunciation can be apparent. Owing to the chapter, Montrealers more oftern use American pronunciation than people in Ontario, which is outstanding feature of Montreal English(P.48). Furthermore, Great Vowel Shift, according to the chapter(P.58), left some characteristics in the dialects, which keep middle English characters.
As a result, dialects above are affected by American English and distinctive in pronunciation.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

2 comments:
Hi Akinori~
As your summaries which you write last few times, it’s very orderly and clearly presented the author’s opinions and the facts on the how dialects influence Canadian English. I also think it’s better to mention the author much more times, such as the “author explained”. According to your critique, you present your opinions on this material objectively. Therefore, I would say you did a good job on evaluating this material. And your presentation skill is improving.
Have a good day!~
Hi Akinory.
Actually I lived in Montreal for 2years when I was 10years old and i still remember they some times used English with some French.
This time i felt familiarity because of my experience.
It was very organized and and easy to comprehend.
Post a Comment